Alarming News: I like Morgan Freeberg. A lot.
American Digest: And I like this from "The Blog That Nobody Reads", because it is -- mostly -- about me. What can I say? I'm on an ego trip today. It won't last.
Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler: We were following a trackback and thinking "hmmm... this is a bloody excellent post!", and then we realized that it was just part III of, well, three...Damn. I wish I'd written those.
Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler: ...I just remembered that I found a new blog a short while ago, House of Eratosthenes, that I really like. I like his common sense approach and his curiosity when it comes to why people believe what they believe rather than just what they believe.
Brutally Honest: Morgan Freeberg is brilliant.
Dr. Melissa Clouthier: Morgan Freeberg at House of Eratosthenes (pftthats a mouthful) honors big boned women in skimpy clothing. The picture there is priceless--keep scrolling down.
Exile in Portales: Via Gerard: Morgan Freeberg, a guy with a lot to say. And he speaks The Truth...and it's fascinating stuff. Worth a read, or three. Or six.
Just Muttering: Two nice pieces at House of Eratosthenes, one about a perhaps unintended effect of the Enron mess, and one on the Gore-y environ-movie.
Mein Blogovault: Make "the Blog that No One Reads" one of your daily reads.
The Virginian: I know this post will offend some people, but the author makes some good points.
Poetic Justice: Cletus! Ah gots a laiv one fer yew...
186k Per Second 4-Block World 84 Rules 9/11 Families A Big Victory Ace of Spades HQ Adam's Blog After Grog Blog Alarming News Alice the Camel Althouse Always Right, Usually Correct America's North Shore Journal American Daily
American Digest American Princess The Anchoress Andrew Ian Dodge Andrew Olmstead Angelican Samizdat Ann's Fuse Box Annoyances and Dislikes Another Rovian Conspiracy Another Think Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler Associated Content The Astute Bloggers Atlantic Blog Atlas Shrugs Atomic Trousers Azamatterofact B Movies Bad Catholicism Bacon Eating Atheist Jew Barking Moonbat Early Warning System The Bastidge The Belmont Club Because I Said So Bernie Quigley Best of the Web Between the Coasts Bidinotto's Blog Big Lizards Bill Hobbs Bill Roggio The Black Republican BlameBush! Blasphemes Blog Curry Blogodidact Blowing Smoke A Blog For All The Blog On A Stick Blogizdat (Just Think About It) Blogmeister USA Blogs For Bush Blogs With A Face Blue Star Chronicles Blue Stickies Bodie Specter Brilliant! Unsympathetic Common Sense Booker Rising Boots and Sabers Boots On Bottom Line Up Front Broken Masterpieces Brothers Judd Brutally Honest Building a Timberframe Home Bush is Hitler Busty Superhero Chick Caerdroia Caffeinated Thoughts California Conservative Cap'n Bob & The Damsel Can I Borrow Your Life Captain's Quarters Carol's Blog! Cassy Fiano Cato Institute CDR Salamander Ceecee Marie Cellar Door Chancy Chatter Chaos Manor Musings Chapomatic Chicago Boyz Chickenhawk Express Chief Wiggles Chika de ManiLA Christianity, Politics, Sports and Me Church and State The Cigar Intelligence Agency Cindermutha Classic Liberal Blog Club Troppo Coalition of the Swilling Code Red Coffey Grinds Cold Fury Colorado Right Common Sense Junction Common Sense Regained with Kyle-Anne Shiver Confederate Yankee Confessions of a Gun Toting Seagull Conservathink Conservative Beach Girl Conservative Blog Therapy Conservative Boot Camp Conservative Outpost Conservative Pup The Conservative Right Conservatives for American Values Conspiracy To Keep You Poor & Stupid Cox and Forkum Cranky Professor Cranky Rants Crazy But Able Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns Create a New Season Crush Liberalism Curmudgeonly & Skeptical D. Challener Roe Da' Guns Random Thoughts Dagney's Rant The Daily Brief The Daily Dish Daily Flute Daily Pundit The Daley Gator Daniel J. Summers Dare2SayIt Darlene Taylor Dave's Not Here David Drake Day By Day Dean's World Decision '08 Debbie Schlussel Dhimmi Watch Dipso Chronicles Dirty Election Dirty Harry's Place Dissecting Leftism The Dissident Frogman Dogwood Pundit Don Singleton Don Surber Don't Go Into The Light Dooce Doug Ross
Down With Absolutes Drink This Dumb Ox News Dummocrats Dustbury Dustin M. Wax Dyspepsia Generation Ed Driscoll The Egoist Eject! Eject! Eject! Euphoric Reality Exile in Portales Everything I Know Is Wrong Exit Zero Expanding Introverse Exposing Feminism Faith and Theology
FARK Fatale Abstraction Feministing Fetching Jen Finding Ponies... Fireflies in the Cloud Fish or Man Flagrant Harbour Flopping Aces Florida Cracker For Your Conservative Pleasure Forgetting Ourselves Fourth Check Raise Fred Thompson News Free Thoughts The Freedom Dogs Gadfly Galley Slaves Gate City Gator in the Desert Gay Patriot The Gallivantings of Daniel Franklin Garbanzo Tunes God, Guts & Sarah Palin Google News GOP Vixen GraniteGrok The Greatest Jeneration Green Mountain Daily Greg and Beth Greg Mankiw Gribbit's Word Guy in Pajamas Hammer of Truth The Happy Feminist Hatless in Hattiesburg The Heat Is On Hell in a Handbasket Hello Iraq Helmet Hair Blog Heritage Foundation Hillary Needs a Vacation Hillbilly White Trash The Hoffman's Hearsay Hog on Ice HolyCoast Homeschooling 9/11 Horsefeathers Huck Upchuck Hugh Hewitt I, Infidel I'll Think of Something Later IMAO Imaginary Liberal In Jennifer's Head Innocents Abroad
Instapundit Intellectual Conservative The Iowa Voice Is This Life? Islamic Danger 4u The Ivory Tower Ivory Tower Adventures J. D. Pendry Jaded Haven James Lileks Jane Lake Makes a Mistake Jarhead's Firing Range The Jawa Report Jellyfish Online Jeremayakovka Jesus and the Culture Wars Jesus' General Jihad Watch Jim Ryan Jon Swift Joseph Grossberg Julie Cork Just Because Your Paranoid... Just One Minute Karen De Coster Keep America at Work KelliPundit Kender's Musings Kiko's House Kini Aloha Guy KURU Lounge La Casa de Towanda Laughter Geneology Leaning Straight Up Left Coast Rebel Let's Think About That Liberal Utopia Liberal Whoppers Liberalism is a Mental Disorder Liberpolly's Journal Libertas Immortalis Life in 3D Linda SOG Little Green Fascists Little Green Footballs Locomotive Breath Ludwig von Mises Institute Lundesigns Rachel Lucas The Machinery of Night The Macho Response Macsmind Maggie's Farm Making Ripples Management Systems Consulting, Inc. Marginalized Action Dinosaur Mark's Programming Ramblings The Marmot's Hole Martini Pundit MB Musings McBangle's Angle Media Research Center The Median Sib Mein Blogovault Melissa Clouthier Men's News Daily Mending Time Michael's Soapbox Michelle Malkin Mike's Eyes Millard Filmore's Bathtub A Million Monkeys Typing Michael Savage Minnesota Democrats Exposed Miss Cellania Missio Dei Missouri Minuteman Modern Tribalist Moonbattery Mother, May I Sleep With Treacher? Move America Forward Moxie Ms. Underestimated My Republican Blog My Vast Right Wing Conspiracy Mythusmage Opines Naked Writing Nation of Cowards National Center Blog Nealz Nuze NeoCon Blonde Neo-Neocon Neptunus Lex Nerd Family Network of Enlightened Women (NeW) News Pundit Nightmare Hall No Sheeples Here NoisyRoom.net Normblog The Nose On Your Face NYC Educator The Oak Tree Obama's Gaffes Obi's Sister Oh, That Liberal Media! Old Hippie One Cosmos One Man's Kingdom One More Cup of Coffee Operation Yellow Elephant OpiniPundit Orion Sector The Other (Robert Stacy) McCain The Outlaw Republican Outside The Beltway Pajamas Media Palm Tree Pundit Papa Knows Part-Time Pundit Pass The Ammo Passionate America Patriotic Mom Pat's Daily Rant Patterico's Pontifications Pencader Days Perfunction Perish the Thought Personal Qwest Peter Porcupine Pettifog Philmon Philosoblog Physics Geek Pigilito Says... Pillage Idiot The Pirate's Cove Pittsburgh Bloggers Point of a Gun Political Byline A Political Glimpse From Ireland Political Party Pooper Possumblog Power Line PrestoPundit Professor Mondo Protein Wisdom Protest Warrior Psssst! Over Here! The Pungeoning Q and O Quiet Moments, Busy Lives Rachel Lucas Radio Paradise Rantburg Real Clear Politics Real Debate Wisconsin Reason Rebecca MacKinnon RedState.Org PAC Red, White and Conservative Reformed Chicks Babbling The Reign of Reason The Religion of Peace Resistance is Futile! Revenge... Reverse Vampyr Rhymes with Cars and Girls Right Angle Right Events Right Mom Right Thinking from the Left Coast Right Truth Right View Wisconsin Right Wing Rocker Right Wing News Rightwingsparkle Robin Goodfellow Rocker and Sage Roger L. Simon Rogue Thinker Roissy in DC Ronalfy Ron's Musings Rossputin Roughstock Journal The Rude Pundit The Rule of Reason Running Roach The Saloon The Salty Tusk Samantha Speaks Samizdata Samson Blinded Say Anything Say No To P.C.B.S. Scillicon and Cigarette Burns Scott's Morning Brew SCOTUSBlog Screw Politically Correct B.S. SCSU Scholars Seablogger See Jane Mom Self-Evident Truths Sensenbrenner Watch Sergeant Lori Seven Inches of Sense Shakesville Shark Blog Sheila Schoonmaker Shot in the Dark The Simplest Thing Simply Left Behind Sister Toldjah Sippican Cottage SISU Six Meat Buffet Skeptical Observer Skirts, Not Pantsuits Small Dead Animals Smallest Minority Solomonia Soy Como Soy Spiced Sass Spleenville Steeljaw Scribe Stephen W. Browne Stilettos In The Sand Still Muttering to Myself SoxBlog Stolen Thunder Strata-Sphere Sugar Free But Still Sweet The Sundries Shack Susan Hill Sweet, Familiar Dissonance Tail Over Tea Kettle Tale Spin Talk Arena Tapscott's Copy Desk Target of Opportunity Tasteful Infidelicacies Tequila and Javalinas Texas Rainmaker Texas Scribbler That's Right Thirty-Nine And Holding This Blog Is Full Of Crap Thought You Should Know Tom Nelson Townhall Toys in the Attic The Truth Tim Blair The TrogloPundit Truth, Justice and the American Way The Truth Laid Bear Two Babes and a Brain Unclaimed Territory Urban Grounds Varifrank Verum Serum Victor Davis Hanson Villanous Company The Virginian Vodkapundit The Volokh Conspiracy Vox Popular Vox Veterana Walls of the City The Warrior Class Washington Rebel Weasel Zippers Webutante Weekly Standard Western Chauvinist A Western Heart Wheels Within Wheels When Angry Democrats Attack! Whiskey's Place Wicking's Weblog Wide Awakes Radio (WAR) Winds of Change.NET Word Around the Net Writing English Woman Honor Thyself "A Work in Progress World According to Carl WorldNet Daily WuzzaDem WyBlog Yorkshire Soul Zero Two Mike SoldierMemo For File IV
Not sure what to make of this blog over here just yet, but it looks like something worth bookmarking. It’s well-written, well enough anyway, and the author has the same pet peeves about what we call “science” that I’ve been having. Possible worthy addition to the sidebar. He elaborates on his complaints here and here and here and here. And here too. Seems to be pretty organized about it.
I have come to be aware of a new logical fallacy being used with increasing regularity by the scientific community, and it’s getting even more frequent use with the release of Al Gore’s new movie. I have called this the Hundred Percent Fallacy but it would be more descriptive to call it something like a Fallacy of Faux Unanimity or some such. It is the love-child of the No True Scotsman fallacy and the False Consensus Effect.
It works like this.
1. Global warming is real and it is caused by humans.
2. One of the most persuasive foundations for #1, is that all scientists agree with it (False Consensus).
3. Response: Bob is a scientist, and he doesn’t agree with #1, so #2 is placed in doubt.
4. (No True Scotsman): Bob is not a real scientist, because he doesn’t agree with #1.
5. All scientists who similarly dissent from #1, are likewise eliminated from the pool, so the veracity of #2 is restored.
The Circular Logic fallacy also has strong influence here. #1 is supposed to be supported by #2, but instead it is used to support #5, which in turn supports #2, which supports #1. There is no one single genesis for the support sequence, no beginning and no end. It just goes in a circle.
That’s a problem that deprives the equation of the proof it is supposed to be providing. The much bigger problem, is that conceptually, a consensus has little or nothing to do with proving anything. The majority amongst a pool of concerned commentators is wrong, fairly often. This has always been the case. And even if it hasn’t, what we call “science” ought to be constructed to allow for this. By design, Science-By-Consensus doesn’t allow for such a thing and can’t allow for such a thing.
Update: I don’t want to lose this one to my old-age forgetfulness either. Looks interesting. Also a worthy potential sidebar addition. “Stilettos in the Sand.”
Update 6-10-06: This guy is listing me in the sidebar, so his site deserves nothing less than a serious looking-over. A pursuit which can’t receive the time and attention from me that it deserves, at the moment, but I’ll fix that shortly.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.